"Fermentation by definition is an anaerobic process. The lactic acid bacteria that carry out dairy and vegetable fermentations can grow in the presence of air but do not use oxygen to generate energy for growth. Using a fermentation lock to exclude oxygen but allow gas to escape will prevent aerobic yeasts and molds from growing. Aerobic yeasts and molds growing on the surface of sauerkraut brines can soften the kraut and produce off flavors. A more serious problem is that yeasts and molds growing aerobically on the surface of vegetable fermentation brines can consume the lactic acid and can cause pH to rise above 4.6, potentially resulting in botulism. Anaerobic fermentation of cabbage, on the other hand, with 2% salt (NaCl) and a temperature around 18C (64F) typically makes very good quality sauerkraut". Dr. Fred Breidt, USDA, Microbiologist
Salt is to brine, like flour is to a well-made bread. Proportions matter, and in both cases, measuring spoons and cups are inadequate tools when it comes to obtaining the correct amount of dry ingredients.
Just like every type of grain has a different weight, every salt has a different weight depending on its grind, density and moisture content. Salt, like flour, is a more reliable, consistent ingredient, when weighed - NOT measured.
Each dish in the above-photo contains 1 level-tablespoon of unrefined, additive-free (no added iodine or anti-caking agents) high-mineral salt, every one a unique brand and grind, ranging from super-fine to large and coarse. Several are moist, some are bone-dry. The brick-red Hawaiian salt (NOT meant to be used as a brine-salt, but instead, a "finishing" salt) contains added clay.
Using a digital scale, set to metric-grams instead U.S. ounces, we weighed each tablespoon of salt.
The end result: Their weights ranged from 10 to 16-grams per tablespoon. That's a whopping 60% difference, negatively or positively impacting salinity! Variations in salinity will impact fermentation.
Salt helps lactic acid bacteria win the microbial race. At a certain salt concentration, lactic acid bacteria grow more quickly than other microbes, and have a competitive advantage.
Below the correct concentration, bad bacteria may survive and spread more easily, possibly out-competing lactic acid bacteria and spoiling your pickles. Also, lactic acid bacteria don't survive in brines that are less than 1%. The "no-salt" fermentation movement doesn't have its roots in traditional fermentation, but instead, in modern misunderstandings about the importance of salt.
Too much salt is also a problem. Lactic acid bacteria cannot thrive, leaving your vegetables unpickled, and instead, salt-cured. Salt-cured has always been a traditional method of fermentation, but it is intentional - meant to kill lactic acid bacteria. What's more, salt-tolerant yeasts can spread more quickly. By consuming lactic acid, yeasts make the pickles less acidic - and more hospitable to spoilage microbes. Science of Cooking
Weigh, Don't Measure Salt
1. Use our easy-to-read brine-tables - based on traditional formulas used by artisan butchers, cheese and pickle-makers.
2. Create the amount of brine you need, whether 1-cup, 1-gallon, or 1-liter, at the proper salinity-level, following our easy-to-read chart.
3. Buy a gram-scale. Digital scales are inexpensive - under $20 - readily available. Make sure there's a "tare" button to zero-out your scale, to obtain the most accurate weight. Scales have a toggle-switch on the underside, one-side labeled "OZ", and the other, "GM". Switch the switch to GM - grams.
Try the convenient Pickl-It brine calculator for best brine recipe!
Which salt is best?
We recommend most dry salts - never wet. Wet salts typically contain clay or dirt, providing coloration (grey, red, brown, etc.) but they also act as a "substrate", a surface on which mold grows. Even when wet salts are baked at a very high temperature, in the hopes of killing mold, rsearch has shown that many mold spores survive. Another issue, not talked about enough, is the lead-content of many northern salts. Click here for a comprehensive report.
Some dry salts that are earth-colored (brown, grey), are "dirty", loaded with rock and dirt debris. To determine if your salt is loaded with debris, heat water to 180F. Remove from heat and add your salt to the water. Allow to cool to room temperature.
All salts are graded, like a good wine, according to their quality and use. We prefer a gourmet-grade for any culinary use, including fermentation.
2%? 3.5%? 5%? 10%? Which brine is best?
Dr. Fred Breidt, a USDA microbiologist and U of NC microbiology professor is quoted in mainstream pro-fermentation articles, as saying that properly-made "lactic acid fermentation is SAFER than canned food". When we talked with Dr. Bredit about Pickl-It anaerobic-fermentation, Dr. Breidt enthusiastically suggested that we could reduce the amount of salt normally used in other methods. Because our anaerobic-container suffocates oxygen-rich mold and yeast, the excess salt is NOT inhibit their growth.
"Anaerobic fermentation of cabbage, on the other hand, with 2% salt (NaCl) and a temperature around 18C (64F) typically makes very good quality sauerkraut."
Dr. Breidt's summary was: "Using the 2% in the Pickl-It, with its anaerobic-conditions, would create a consistently good end-product with superior results in taste, flavor and color retention."
This has been verified by our customers who regularly tell us they appreciate the "clean" flavor of Pickl-It foods, something many of them tried creating, but failed, when using other containers and methods.
2% Salinity: Carrot sticks, shreds, slices; broccoli, cauliflower, pearl onions, green beans (add grape leaves to preserve color), asparagus, green/red peppers de-seeded, parsnip, kohlrabi, Jerusalem artichoke, zucchini (whole), sliced radish, whole-small radish, whole green tomato, are but a few examples. Quick guide: Fill the Pickl-It with food (dice, chunk, whole, etc.) to 1-inch below the "shoulder". Add 2% brine to the "shoulder" so your vegetables are covered with 1-inch of brine.
For kraut, use 22 grams of salt for every 5-pounds of shredded cabbage. Our consulting microbiologists provided us with this tested ratio which results in a 2% brine. Alternate layers of cabbage/salt and press every 2-3 inches using a wooden tool. The goal is to press out oxygen-pockets, not to mash the cabbage. Continue building layers until the cabbage is compacted, 1-inch below the shoulder of the jar. For more details, see the kraut recipe.
3.5% Salinity: Pickled cukes for pickling-varieties such as Kirby or Boston. Fermented short-term (7-days on-counter, then 2 weeks in fridge) creates "half-sour" - still half-white, somewhat green inside. More fermentation-time creates evenly-distributed green color and sublime flavor. See: "Are My Pickled-Cukes Done?"
10% Salinity: For those serious about brine-curing meat, crafting authentic feta-cheese, pepper-mashes, curing green olives, authentic fish-sauce, and shrimp-sauce.
Try the convenient Pickl-It brine calculator for most accurate brine recipe!
Chart #1: Water is U.S. Measurement, salt in grams.
Examples: To create 8-cups of brine at 2% salinity, use 38 grams of salt. To create 3-cups of brine at a 2% salinity, add the amount of salt called for in the columns under 1-cup (5 grams) and 2-cups (10 grams) which equals 15-grams of salt. If creating a 1% brine, simply divide the 2% salt grams by 50%. To make a 1% brine for 2-cups of water, use half of the 5-grams, ROUND DOWN to 2 grams.
Hot water dissolve: Coarse-grind, unrefined sea-salt, requires using a hot-water method: heat water to near-boil, add salt, stirr repeatedly until salt dissolves, then wait until the brine cools to room temperature.
Cold-water dissolve: Our Pickl-It Brine-Grind Sea Salt is ground into a powder which dissolves instantly in cold water. No more heating, stirring, waiting. Instead, brines are simple-to-create on an as-needed basis, and their nutrients are retained, not destroyed by heat.
If you are following the "Getting Started with Pickl-It" tutorial, you may navigate to the following:
Continue to #6: Filling Airlocks with Water
OR Return to, Getting Started With Pick-It - Home Page
|by Kathleen in Recipes | Permalink|
Did you know...
Numbers 11:5 ““We remember the fish which we used to eat free in Egypt, the cucumbers and the melons and the leeks and the onions and the garlic…”. The Hebrew word for cucumber is “kishshuim“.
—Cucumbers In the Bible
I was intrigued by the whey-method although I kept thinking, "This really can't work. It sounds like a bad idea." I had my undergrad class check out whey-ferment vs no-whey, using the German crocks. Wow. I should have listened to my original thinking. Bad idea! Don't use whey! Not only is it low-count, but the flavor is awful and the texture even worse! Love your Pickl-It! Great tool for teaching!
—Gary, University Microbiology Professor